Ryan Forsyth Main Project Report Part 1

My final project consisted of a dynamic model sailboat, floating in a tank with a aesthetic based on Romantic and Dutch Golden Age Maritime Art.

I have always loved model boats: at home in Maryland, almost every house has one. My house has several; I love looking at them and exploring their intricacies. When presented with the final project in Aesthetics of Design, building a model boat came to mind instantly, but most model boats are static, this project needed to be dynamic. What better way to make a model boat dynamic than by putting it in water and letting it do its thing-float?

image from handcraftedmodelships.com 

     This is the general idea, but instead of putting the boat on a stand, I wanted it to sit in water in a tank. I knew this would be challenging, a bit costly, and very time consuming, but I had built models before, so I thought it was possible.

     My original plan was to build a model from a high-end kit, using balsa, model glue, canvas, model paint, etc. This method can produce very high-quality models with excellent detail and good accuracy of scale. This model, the “Sharpie Schooner”, is an example of a kit boat, one my dad and I built a few years ago.

image from midwestproducts.com

     I realized, however, that there were several problems with this approach. First of all, almost all models are too large a scale for the fish tank I was using-the mast would stick out way above the top of the tank. Second, these models are rather expensive and VERY time consuming, and time and money are things I do not have much of these days. Lastly, and most importantly, these models rarely float. They are not designed with the intention of ever seeing water, as a result, there are numerous seams under the waterline that unless glued completely would leak and sink the boat. In addition, the deck fittings, sails, and paint are not meant to be exposed to water, and water would most likely damage them. So instead of using a more advanced wooden kit, I opted instead for a simple, plastic set. The set I used has a one-piece hull, so no seams for water to get in, and simple, waterproof construction. It is also small enough to fit in the tank, and within my budgetary restrictions (the set was $25).

picture of boat under construction

     I began construction on my boat, and had it finished within my manufacturing timeline’s guidelines-with a week to spare before the expo to allow time to deal with unforeseen setbacks. One such setback was that the boat did not stay upright. I imagine this is a problem with all model sailboats not specifically designed for floating: they are too top heavy, and instantly capsize. On a real sailboat, there is much more weight in the hull than above the deck, but a model sailboat does not share that weight distribution. I tried putting ballast in the hull, but to put enough to keep it from capsizing sunk the boat, so this did not work. I instead tied a piece of clear fishing line around the top of the mast and taped it to either side of the tank, which held the mast upright. It does not look great, but it is hard for the casual eye to notice, and keeps the boat framed in the center of the tank.

     With the boat completed, I could shift my focus to the aesthetic. With the boat being modeled after a pirate ship, I decided the best aesthetic would be romantic-style/Dutch golden era-style maritime art. These style were very popular from the late 1500s to the late 1600s and early 1700s to the mid 1800s, respectively; two of the most important contributors were T G Dutton (romantic era) and Cornelis Verbeeck (Dutch golden era). Examples of maritime art, most typically “boat portraits”, can be found in almost every major classical collection or museum. I especially liked the idea of “boat portrait” art, because the model could replace the boat in a painting, while the backdrop could remain. I used a TV with various examples of maritime art for the background, and used Verbeeck’s “An Engagement Between the Spanish and the Dutch” for the middleground (this was attached to the back of the tank). I selected this painting in particular because its color scheme matches closely with the colors and texture of the pebbles on the bottom of the tank, making the middleground seem more seamless and tying the physical model into the painting.

The end result, viewed from the side and above

 

 

Previous Post
Main Project Presentation: iTunes Hologram
Next Post
Final Project Report 2: Laser Cut and Etched Nightstand

5 Comments. Leave new

  • Ryan Forsyth
    Katie Gresh
    May 10, 2017 9:22 pm

    Nice project! Seeing the progress of your project throughout the semester was very interesting! The final project turned out very well. I like how you used the fish tank and staged the boat in water. Using the clear thread was great to keep the boat upright. The different models you built was a big design iteration and the final project turned out very well! The backdrop colors and scenery aesthetically go very well with the colors and design of the sail boat! The pebbles are also a very nice touch to bring everything together and are the perfect color. The project looked aesthetically pleasing and cohesively put together with a matching backdrop. The inspiration for your project from your hobby of sailing is really good too, and the interest you had in constructing a model sail boat shows. Great job!

    Reply
  • Ryan Forsyth
    Branden Goldenberg
    May 5, 2017 11:47 am

    Although it may not have turned out exactly as planned at the start, it is still a fun art project! It is as interactive as one could ask and it is pleasing to the eye. Well done. You seemed to keep on running into problems! I wonder how well a boat that YOU designed would float and remain stable? I bet it would be better than the kit!

    Reply
  • Ryan Forsyth
    Oksana Schuppan
    May 5, 2017 10:43 am

    The way you attached the boat with transparent threads to the sides of the tank is hardly noticeable and highly successful. Your project takes me back in time and the aesthetic is clear. I love how the water is not crystal clear like the rough see in the painting backdrop. Great work!

    Reply
  • Ryan Forsyth
    Benjamin Fried
    May 3, 2017 12:40 pm

    Great idea. I’m a big fan of these model boats, and even have a few of them in my house. This is a unique idea that I’ve never seen before.

    The maritime art aspect is interesting as well, there are some interesting and historic art pieces. It’d be great if you could match the ship from that era to the picture in the background.

    Reply
  • Ryan Forsyth
    Alexander Lien
    May 2, 2017 12:35 pm

    Great idea on the project. Your ability to adapt to issues was impressive too. Deciding to use a plastic hull was a great move since that eliminates the opportunity for water to seep in through any seams and sink the boat. Also using the clear line was a great move. I didn’t even notice the clear line on the mast at expo until I got really close and gave this project a serious look.

    I think you could have also helped your aesthetic with some props in the tank. Since you were going for the pirate theme I feel like you could have thrown in some treasure chests or reefs or things you might find in fish tanks.

    Anyhow, great job. This project is really neat and I think the path and aesthetic you chose are also very unique.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.

Menu